Hey buymeasoda,
I can understand the pains of maintaining two layouts, but I got to put my vote down as disliking the new square tabs style, currently just using v1 manually installed (had some bumps with Package Control’s auto update thingy). It looks quite nice in the picture, but I dont know, seems kinda klunky on XP (yeah, XP, work computer naturally). Edit: and yes, thank you for an awesome theme. Been using it virtually since the moment I started configuring sublimetext.